How inclusive leaders can help overcome division at work
By Jo Faragher on 10 July 2024
Last week was election week in the UK, and across the world this year, we’ll see 64 countries go to the polls – more collective voters than ever in history. But while most people exercise their democratic rights without much fanfare, political and other societal tensions can come to the fore in the workplace. Many organisations are feeling the reverberations of the so-called culture wars and increased polarisation of views – and leaders often don’t feel confident to deal with this.
“Often the culture wars are stoked by unfounded fears. People regurgitate ‘facts’ without doing the research themselves and looking for nuance which compounds their confirmation bias,” says Toluwani Farinto, partner and ethnicity and social mobility specialism lead at Utopia. We hear across society and the DEI landscape in businesses that there’s been an ‘overcorrection’, for example if the company has been increasing its efforts to recruit more people from under-represented groups. The best response in these situations is to present them with data, he adds. “Leaders can equip themselves with data that highlights the businesses aim to be representative of its consumer or region in which it operates – whether that’s census data, immigration data, other external and internal trends – and this can provide insight to unpick the fear that exists around these popular narratives, while reinforcing these aren’t arbitrary efforts to be more diverse for the sake of being more diverse.”
Providing insight into the workings for these decisions is key in these situations. Farinto continues: “You may not convince them to change their minds at first, but at least you’ve had a more meaningful conversation. Often certain narratives can proliferate due to certain fears and challenges the dominant groups may be feeling.” Inclusive leadership is just as important here to ensure we are curious about these challenges and have empathy, rather than labelling them, he adds. Being empathetic while holding people accountable if they’re spreading extreme or unfounded views is a good approach as a first step.
Inclusive role models
Koma Gandy, vice president, leadership and business segment at software company Skillsoft, agrees. “Inclusive leaders fight polarisation at work by fostering an environment where diverse perspectives are valued and respected. They actively listen to their team members, ensuring everyone feels heard and understood, and model the type of behaviours that aspiring inclusive leaders should follow,” she says. “This approach helps to bridge gaps between differing points of view, which facilitates understanding and healthy conflict where diverse opinions are encouraged and welcomed.”
Leaders that role model these behaviours can also engender a more inclusive culture, which in turn can generate better business outcomes. Research from Deloitte has shown that teams with inclusive leaders are 17% more likely to report high performance, and 20% more likely to make high-quality decisions. Almost three in 10 say they work together more collaboratively. Gandy adds: “Leaders committed to inclusivity also consistently demonstrate respect and empathy in their interactions. By doing so, they set the standard for the rest of the team, encouraging a culture of belonging and mutual respect. By prioritising diversity and inclusion, team cohesion is advanced – leading to greater innovation and productivity.”
Organisations can build these leadership skills – they don’t necessarily come naturally. Learning and development programmes in areas such as active listening, managing conflict, team-building and strategic thinking can help, advises Gandy. Mentoring and coaching can help leaders identify their strengths and potential areas for development. Regular self-reflection pays off, she adds: “Leaders should actively seek feedback on their communication style, decision-making process, and ability to motivate and inspire others. Regular self-reflection can also help them identify personal biases and areas for improvement.”
Leadership pipeline
Sophie Randles, director at Livingston James Group, an executive search firm, says future leaders need to be given these tools early in their career to ensure they succeed. “Companies should look to review their recruitment and promotion criteria to ensure inclusive leadership qualities are included,” she explains.“They need to recruit, promote, and retain inclusive leaders who demonstrate these qualities and empower them to inspire and engage their teams. They could also review management development and reward programmes to ensure inclusive leadership behaviours are promoted and rewarded.” This type of leadership development may differ from what companies have offered in the past, however. “Navigating this complex landscape requires more than just traditional leadership skills; it demands empathy, transparency, and a proactive approach to fostering unity. In my opinion, for bridging these divides, leaders need to be able to create spaces for open, respectful dialogue where diverse views can be expressed and heard,” she adds.
When it comes to divisive political debate, leaders should listen and learn from employees before acting, says Katy Morrison, EDI lead at leadership consultancy Connect Three. “There is often a noticeable generational divide on various cultural and political issues, such as Brexit, climate change, and social justice causes. Younger generations often have different priorities and values compared to older ones, creating a challenge for leaders to bridge this gap,” she says. “There is a growing mistrust in political institutions and leaders among the public, and therefore the workforce. Scandals, perceived incompetence, and the influence of special interest groups have eroded trust, making it harder for leaders to gain support and implement policies.”
By creating safe spaces, leaders can understand where teams are at, and encourage employees to set professional boundaries or establish “off-limit” topics so people can work together more cohesively, even if their views differ, she adds. On top of this, organisations can drive accountability by developing metrics that assess the inclusiveness of leaders. “This can include tracking the representation within teams, inclusion-related engagement scores, and their visible commitment to building inclusion within teams. Leaders should be assessed and rewarded based on their ability to foster inclusive environments. Quite often we find this is missed during performance-based conversations, and so leaders do not see this as a priority,” says Morrison.
Future-proofing the organisation
Much has been made of a skills gap in inclusive leadership, but Farinto believes we all have tremendous capacity to “learn and unlearn” new behaviours – whatever generation or leadership school of thought we come from. “Theory alone is not enough – leaders need to learn how they make inclusive leadership relevant for their organisation, what the key tenets and values are that drive it for them. Because every business is different, though, having that data piece is fundamental. That insight helps you to understand how you do something that is outside what you’re used to doing,” he adds.
In years to come, the world is unlikely to get less chaotic, so building these skills is essential in the long term. Gandy concludes: “With companies operating globally and remotely more than ever before, inclusive leaders who understand and respect cultural differences can foster better international collaboration and drive global success. Inclusive environments contribute to higher employee satisfaction and engagement. Inclusive teams are also more resilient and adaptable to change, as diverse perspectives can lead to more innovative solutions and better problem-solving in times of crisis or change.”
View more d&i Leaders articles
d&i Leaders is a global community of senior diversity, inclusion and HR focused professionals, looking to collaborate, network and accelerate their workplace inclusion strategy.
