Does D&I ignore white men, and what can we do about it?
By Jo Faragher on 20 June 2024
One of the most popular questions among the audience at d&i Leaders’ recent global forum covered an issue that’s not always commonly discussed. It was about how we get white, senior-level men, typically in the majority in organisations, on board with inclusion. Tiernan Brady, global director of inclusion at law firm Clifford Chance, was one of the panellists to bring this up, saying: “Why do men think inclusion is against them – how do we bring the campaigns to the people, rather than expecting people to come to the campaign?”
Daniele Fiandaca, founder of Token Man Consulting, was an attendee at the event and feels there is a sense of not making the “in group” suddenly feel uncomfortable, which is why it’s not addressed. “It’s the elephant in the room,” he says. “I think there is discomfort because it feels like we’re telling the industry it’s failing. It’s the biggest elephant but also the biggest opportunity.” According to the White Men’s Leadership study in 2022, almost 70% of men feel “forgotten” by D&I initiatives in organisations, despite the fact that globally, they possess more than 40% of the leadership positions in companies. Fiandaca argues that D&I itself is often not diverse enough, and this is where the industry is going wrong. “This is where the shift will come from, it will help us to open up that space,” he says. “Too often we lead from hurt rather than heart in D&I – people who have been harmed by the system feel angry, but if you lead from this start point you create disconnection.”
Overcoming fear
Coming from a point where we understand men and their own challenges, rather than apportioning ‘blame’, is a more constructive approach. “We can invest in men in the short term so they can see the issues, and understand that they are still in the positions of power where they can effect change,” he adds. “Where D&I has got it wrong is in only speaking to men as allies or discussing recruitment. Fear can get in the way because it gets in the way of learning. But saying the wrong thing is often how you learn. Often any feelings of being open soon get crushed if you realise you’re being judged.”
Lee Chambers, psychologist and director of Male Allies UK, argues that the challenges in engaging men can come from a misunderstanding of privilege. “Privilege is not what you have, it’s what you don’t have to face,” he explains. “This might be bigger things but it’s often those small, inner thoughts you don’t have to have because you’re in a dominant group. You don’t face microaggressions in the same way.” Likewise, there are many men who feel a “level of apathy” about D&I because they feel the issues have been solved or addressed – just look at recent research suggesting 53% of both sexes think gender equality has gone far enough. “We see this a lot, people asking ‘why should we?’, ‘why is this relevant to us?’ because there’s a lot they don’t see that still hasn’t changed,” he adds.
To engage this audience, D&I teams need to focus on listening rather than broadcasting, Chambers suggests: “Historically D&I training has taken a bit of a stick approach, it feels like it’s designed to slap people around the head. This won’t inspire people to take small and consistent actions and understand why they’re doing so.” Labelling these conversations as inclusion training will also create a “separation” and discourage men from participating, he adds: “It’s about highlighting how everyone has faced exclusion at some point in their life, and getting them to think about how that felt. Most men care; they’re just not conditioned to express that.” There are positive consequences for mental wellbeing too, as men often ‘bottle up’ stress or workplace concerns and burn out, while women tend to release it.
Broader skills
“It could be an internal group, for example through a gender network, or facilitated externally,” advises Chambers. “The first step is to meet people where they’re at.” One approach is to run a workshop where participants draw up actions and become accountable for them. Often these activities lead men to go on a personal as well inclusion growth journey that can improve their professional interactions more widely. “These skills are increasingly valuable for leaders in our volatile world – they allow you to work alongside people from all backgrounds. The next generation are not willing to be led by fear and power exertion,” he adds.
Sandra Ondraschek-Norris, VP of global learning design at Catalyst, believes too many organisations don’t understand what it means to engage men in D&I, what’s in it for them and why it is a key leadership competency. “This needs to be unpacked, we need to understand why there is discomfort around this,” she says. “If they are serious about D&I, organisations simply cannot do it without senior leaders, who are mostly still white men.” Often, she says, leaders are committed to inclusion but are not sure how to turn that commitment into meaningful action. “They’re also overwhelmed by the complexity of the topic, and you can’t discuss inclusion without looking at masculinity and masculine norms,” she adds.
Breaking down gender norms
Opening up about the impact of masculine norms on the wider organisation can often feel like a relief, says Ondraschek-Norris. “When we talk about patriarchal masculinity, there can be a gap between the expectations around that and what the men in the room actually want – their values, their ideals, their real lives and relationships,” she says. A gender partnership approach can look at the causes of gender imbalance in organisations, the barriers to equity and how men can drive change “in a credible, informed and authentic way”, she adds. If senior leaders embrace this, line managers will see these behaviours modelled and this creates a critical mass of people who support advocacy and allyship.
Fiandaca believes the results of getting men on board with inclusion can be transformative. “It’s disappointing the industry is not talking about it more,” he says. “Part of engaging men is recognising that they also need support, and that we need to bring them on that journey.”
View more d&i Leaders articles
d&i Leaders is a global community of senior diversity, inclusion and HR focused professionals, looking to collaborate, network and accelerate their workplace inclusion strategy.
